top of page

Suspicious of your sales

3 hours ago
4 min read

Fact-checking your ‘sale’ price.

As most of us do, we ‘collect’ items in our Amazon cart, and over the months and weeks leading up to Black Friday, I have gotten notifications of the prices increasing and decreasing, mostly by cents, rarely by dollars. So when I see these ‘Save 40%’ messages, it feels disconnected from what I have been passively paying attention to over the past few weeks.

I’m not the only one; this triggered some questions. Amazon has been under public scrutiny about the real strategy behind its ‘was’ pricing.


Ireland’s customer regulator surveyed over 1000 consumers this month and found that 73% do not trust that the Black Friday deals are real. Three-quarters, that’s up from 61% in 2022. And I am sure, like most consumers, we are skeptical, and some consumers are doing their own price comparisons. BCG polled more than 10,000 shoppers across ten countries, and only 54% believe Black Friday prices are actually lower than usual.


This is not to say all strike-out pricing is false, but if you run an online store, a brick-and-mortar store, or sell online at all, be prepared for your customers to be a little more skeptical.


Why it worked?

We love feeling like we got a good deal; the thrill of the hunt, plus the satisfaction of saving money, is pretty compelling.


When it comes to shopping, we anchor to prices (numbers) and use that as a reference point. Tversky and Kahneman showed decades ago that the first number we see becomes the reference point, and everything after gets judged against it. $200 crossed out next to $149 doesn't register as $149. It registers as $51 saved. In behavioral economics, our consideration is based in reference dependence – judging a price not only on whether we think we are getting value, or if the price reflects the item, but referencing it against the price we think should be normal.


Where have we seen it:

Amazon was required to pay $1.1 million in 2017 to settle with the Canadian Competition Bureau over ‘list prices” on the Canadian Amazon website. Prices were unchecked; Amazon trusted suppliers, assuming fair pricing (even today, I still see random items at skyrocketing prices). In the US, a proposed class action lawsuit filed in September 2025 claimed that Amazon Prime Day discount ‘deals’ used percentages based on inflated original listing prices. – aka, prices were increased only to offer a significant discount on Prime Day. An example referenced is a kids tablet at 40% off of $119.00, selling for roughly $72 in the previous 90 days, with the Prime Day discounted price being $72.18. No deal.

Sale prices and suspicious customers

Our very own, now nearly depleted, Hudson Bay Company settled for $4.5 million in 2019 with the same Competition Bureau over alleged price fixing, artificially inflating prices to offer a discount later, in this case on ‘clearance’ mattresses.


Overstock lost its appeal in 2017, forced to pay $6.8 million after nudging suppliers to raise prices so markdowns were even more exaggerated. Boohoo also settled for an outstanding $197 million over ‘was’ pricing, a strike out of prices that were never charged.


I’ve never had clients use this practice, there is typically not enough of a sales benefit to risk your reputation or trust with your clients.

 

Training your customers

I have always known that sales have a place. Sometimes a sale is great to clear out stock; other times it can incentivize urgency of purchases. I think we’re starting to blur the line between sales and our customers, or alternatively, we are training customers to only shop sales.


Lululemon updates their ‘We Made Too Much’ on Thursdays; some people only shop then. Black Friday is a great time to buy a vacuum, so many people will wait for it; TVs on Boxing Day. At some point, we start to consider our shopping habits around when it makes the most sense, rather than when we need it.


We’ve also taken away that sense of urgency when it comes to sales. Black Friday did not exist in Canada for many years, and now, it’s weeks long in a span of less than 8 years. There is no rush to purchase on Boxing Day if it lasts 2 weeks and not just 24 hours.


Loss Aversion shows up when we think we have overpaid, knowing there are seasons of sales. If you think you should spend $500 on a TV and have to spend $600 because it’s the wrong time of year, you feel like you have lost $100, and you feel that more than you feel the benefits of the discount.


So what do we trust?

Proof will always win. Amazon has added the Alexa shopper that will show you the trend in prices; customers love the security of the ‘money-back guarantee’ of a promise of a low price. Verified purchase reviews give us confidence; influencers and scarcity tactics do not.  


Consumers will scrutinize even more, and with AI, access is greater and at their fingertips. As a seller, keeping track of pricing and your sales will protect you.

Before you buy.


Aside from the responsible asking of whether or not you actually need the item, check the price history.

Comments


bottom of page